Freshly Baked (358)

Fresh Bake Shop Assorted Donuts, 1 each, $0.99

sweetened golden brown donut

Fresh Bake Marble Layer Cake Vanilla Icing, 40 oz, $24.99

Prepared Fresh In Store - 1/4 Sheet - Custom Decorating Available - 24 Hour Notice Needed

6 Pack Yellow & Chocolate Cupcakes W/Vanilla Icing & Picks, $5.99

Something for everyone - moist and delicioius yellow and chocolate cupcakes, topped with creamy vanilla icing, customized for your celebration

Store Baked Dutch Apple Pie, $6.99

made with NY Apples topped with Cinnamon Sugar crunch in a flaky crust

Boston Cream Cake, $11.99

moist yellow cake layers filled with silky pastry cream and covered in chocolate ganache

12 Pack Candy Cookies, $3.49

A sweet buttery sugar cookie loaded with colorful chocolate candies- tasty for everyday cravings!

12 Pack Chocolate Chip Cookies, $3.49

A soft buttery flavored classic recipe full of semi sweet chocolate chips, one bite will leave you satisfied!

Banana Crème Pie, $7.49

Banana Crème Pie

1/4 Sheet Brownies with Fudge Icing, $6.99

Classic rich, and fudgy Chocolate Brownie topped with Fudge Icing.

Store Baked Pumpkin Pie, $6.99

Pumpkins from the Amish farmlands of Pennsylvania make this dish a must. The blend of pumpkin and spices will add to that warm Holiday feel.

6 Pack Holiday Cupcakes, $5.99

Festive and delicious, perfect for a party, dessert or snack our moist, delicious holiday cupcakes are a crowd pleaser

1/4 Sheet Marble Cake with Vanilla Icing, $24.99

the best of both worlds. moist, light chocolate and yellow cake, finished with sweet vanilla icing

12 Pack Yellow & Chocolate Cupcakes With Vanilla Icing & Picks, $10.99

Something for everyone - moist and delicioius yellow and chocolate cupcakes, topped with creamy vanilla icing, customized for your celebration

12 Pack Yellow & Chocolate Cupcakes With Vanilla Icing & Picks, $10.99

Something for everyone - moist and delicioius yellow and chocolate cupcakes, topped with creamy vanilla icing, customized for your celebration

Store Made Large Cream Puffs, $3.79

french pastry filled with custard topped with powdered sugar

2 Pack Apple Turnovers, $3.69

Flaky puff pastry dough, filled with apples, our turnover is a classic breakfast, dessert or snack item.

Bowl & Basket Strawberry Swirl Cheesecake, 16 oz, $9.99

Bowl & Basket Strawberry Swirl Cheesecake, 16 oz

4 Pack Katie Reilly's Blueberry Scones, $3.49

A biscuit like texture. Crusty exterior and tender light crumb packed with plump blueberries

Bowl & Basket New York Style Cheesecake, 40 oz, $19.99

Bowl & Basket New York Style Cheesecake, 40 oz

Bowl & Basket Variety Sampler Cheesecake, 40 oz, $19.99

New York Style, Strawberry Swirl, Mississippi Mud, Chocolate Marble, Raspberry Swirl, Turtle

6 Pack Yellow Cupcakes W/ Vanilla Icing, $5.99

Tender, moist and delicious classic yellow cupcakes topped with creamy vanilla icing

Fresh Bake Shop Apple Cider Cake Donuts - 6 count, 12 oz, $5.99

SEASONAL, Autumn Favorite. Available Saturday & Sunday Only. Baked Fresh Daily - Package of 6 - Available Glazed, Sugared or Plain

4 Pack Banana Nut Puffin Muffin, $5.49

Large Homestyle Muffin packed with natural banana flavoring, real bananas, and crunchy walnuts

12 Pack Raspberry Pastry Bites, $3.99

Bite sized puff pastry treats with delicious raspberry filling

12 Pack Strawberry Cheese Pastry Bites, $3.99

Bite sized puff pastry treats with delicious strawberry and cheese filling

Mini Blueberry Snail Danish, 6 Pack, $3.69

A light,rich, flaky pastry filled with fruits, nuts, or cheese.

Variety Mini Snail Danish, 6 Pack, $3.69

A light,rich, flaky pastry filled with fruits, nuts, or cheese.

12 Pack Sugar Cookies, $3.49

Perfectly buttery, sweet, and tender- a cookie that makes everyday special

Dessert Shells, 5 oz, $2.59

Dessert Shells, 5 oz

12 Pack Yellow & Chocolate Cupcakes With Vanilla Icing, $10.99

Something for everyone - moist and delicioius yellow and chocolate cupcakes, topped with creamy vanilla icing